Which Pasta Sauce Reigns Supreme? A Flavor Profiling Holds The Answer

We gathered the top pasta sauces on the market, ranging from traditional marinara to spicy arrabbiata.

BY STAFF @THE BRIMLY TEST KITCHEN

April 26, 2023

Image Source/Editors @ Brimly

The selection of the products showcased on Brimly is made independently by our editors. Nevertheless, if you buy something through our retail links, we may earn a commission as an affiliate.

As the Brimly Test Kitchen staffers were seated around the table, we debated: which pasta sauce reigns supreme? We knew we had to get to the bottom of this essential culinary question, so we decided to conduct a simple taste test.

We gathered the top pasta sauces on the market, ranging from traditional marinara to spicy arrabbiata. Then, we set up our tasting station with bowls of freshly boiled pasta and a bevy of spoons.

We dove into each sauce while carefully noting flavor, texture, and overall appeal. As we tasted each sauce, we found ourselves getting more and more passionate about our preferences. For example, there were debates over the merits of chunky vs. smooth sauce and whether or not a hint of sweetness was desirable.

But as we took our final bites, one sauce emerged as the clear winner: This spicy sauce had just the right amount of kick, with a rich and complex flavor profile that left us wanting more.

As we celebrated our victory, we couldn't help but feel relieved that we had finally put this important culinary question to rest. We knew our verdict on the best pasta sauce would go down in history, and we couldn't wait to share our findings with the world.

When it comes to pasta sauces, the options are endless. We've tasted and tested five different sauces to help you find your perfect match. Here are our reviews:

Dave's Gourmet Spicy Heirloom Tomato Sauce

Flavor: Spicy tomato goodness •Texture: Smooth and thick•Appearance: Bold, vibrant red•Nutrition: Low calorie, vegan• Allergens: None

First up was Dave's Gourmet Spicy Heirloom Tomato Sauce. This sauce has a unique kick that sets it apart from other tomato sauces. It also has a hint of sweetness and is Made with heirloom tomatoes and a blend of spices; it's perfect for those who like a little heat with their pasta. It is both gluten-free and vegan. The sauce comes in a glass jar with a fun and simple label design. It's priced around $9-$17 per 25 oz jar. Our staff appreciated the bold flavor and the use of high-quality ingredients.

SHOP AT AMAZON

Organico Bello Marinara Sauce

Flavor: Rich and savory•Texture: Chunky and hearty•Appearance: Rustic and vibrant red•Nutrition: Organic, low calorie, low sugar, gluten-free•Allergens: None

We then moved on to Organico Bello Marinara Sauce. This sauce has a classic taste, made with organic tomatoes, garlic, and basil. Its rich and hearty texture makes it perfect for those who prefer a traditional pasta sauce without any added frills. The sauce comes in a glass jar with a simple, elegant label design. It's priced around $9-$13 per 25 oz jar. Our staff appreciated the simplicity and purity of the ingredients, as well as the robust flavor.

SHOP AT AMAZON

Truff Spicy Arrabbiata Sauce

Flavor: Truffle-infused, spicy•Texture: Smooth and velvety •Appearance: Dark red with visible specks of black truffle • Nutrition: Low calorie, vegan, gluten-free•Allergens: Contains truffle

Enter Truff Spicy Arrabbiata Sauce. Truff is not just any pasta sauce; it has a luxurious and complex flavor profile. This sauce combines spicy peppers, savory spices, and a hint of truffle oil. It has a unique flavor pairs well with any pasta, especially with penne. It's made with high-quality ingredients and is both gluten-free and vegan. The sauce comes in a glass bottle with a sleek and modern label design. It's priced around $11-$19 per 17 oz bottle. Our staff was blown away by the complex flavor profile and the heat that lingers on the palate.

SHOP AT WHOLE FOODS

Just like Home Kitchen Recipes Zesty Tomato Basil & Cheese Sauce

Flavor: Tangy and savory•Texture: Creamy and smooth•Appearance: Light orange with visible specks of basil•Nutrition: low in calories, fat-free•Allergens: Contains dairy

Then we moved on to Just like Home Kitchen Recipes Zesty Tomato Basil & Cheese Sauce. This sauce has a rich and creamy texture with a zesty flavor perfect for those who like a little spice. It's an excellent choice for any pasta dish with tomatoes, basil, and cheese. The aroma is rich and tomato-forward, with a fragrant basil note and a subtle hint of cheese. The sauce is made with high-quality ingredients and is both gluten-free and vegetarian. It comes in a plastic jar with a colorful label design. The price is around $10-$25 per 25 oz jar. Our staff appreciated the homemade taste and the indulgent texture.

SHOP AT AMAZON

Monte Bene Tomato Basil Sauce

Flavor: Rich and savory•Texture: bits of tomato and basil•Appearance: Bright red• Nutrition: No artificial flavors or preservatives, low calorie, gluten-free•Allergens: None

And finally, Monte Bene Tomato Basil Sauce. This sauce has a bright and fresh flavor, thanks to vine-ripened tomatoes and fresh basil. Also, it is both gluten-free and non-GMO, making it perfect for those who prefer a lighter pasta sauce that still packs in the flavor. The sauce comes in a glass jar with a classic and rustic label design. It's priced around $7-$20 per 24 oz jar. Again, our staff appreciated the simple ingredients and the delicious taste.

SHOP AT AMAZON

Each of these pasta sauces has something unique, but we voted up Truff Spicy Arrabbiata Sauce! This sauce is the supreme sauce with its luxurious and complex flavor profile. Truffle oil, in particular, adds a unique taste that elevates the sauce to a new level. Truff sauce is perfect for pasta dishes and can also be used as a dip, marinade, or spread. It's a versatile sauce that can be used in various ways to add a touch of luxury and heat to any dish.

Truff sauce has gained a loyal following among foodies and chefs, who swear by its addictive taste and versatility. It's also worth noting that Truff sauce is made with high-quality ingredients and is free from artificial preservatives or flavors.

So if you're looking for the ultimate pasta sauce to elevate your next meal, look no further than Truff arrabbiata. Trust us; we've spent hours testing to make this decision! But, of course, it wasn't all serious business in the Brimly Test Kitchen. We couldn't resist making a few jokes along the way. One team member suggested we create a "Pasta Sauce March Madness" bracket for next year's taste test. Who knows, we'll even take it to the streets and challenge other test kitchens to a sauce-off. But in all seriousness, we had a blast taste-testing pasta sauces and coming to a final verdict. It's always a good day in the Brimly Test Kitchen when we indulge in delicious food and have a few laughs. And who knows, next week we'll tackle another essential culinary debate: which cheese reigns supreme on a pizza? Stay tuned!