The 5 Best Food Storage Container Sets for Bakers Who Pretend to Have It Together
“For those who are tired of freezer bags.”
BY STAFF @THE BRIMLY TEST KITCHENApril 3, 2025
Image Source/Editors @ Brimly
The selection of the products showcased on Brimly is made independently by our editors. Nevertheless, if you buy something through our retail links, we may earn a commission as an affiliate.
Keeping flour, sugar, and other baking staples fresh (and your pantry neat) is a constant struggle for bakers. I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve fumbled a paper bag of flour or found brown sugar hardened into a brick. After years of baking—and testing a mix of flimsy tubs and hand-me-down canisters—I finally invested in real storage solutions. Below, I’ve rounded up the five best container sets for bakers. Each pick shines in its own way, from really tight seals to space-saving designs, so you can choose what fits your kitchen and baking needs.
Best Overall for Baking Essentials: OXO Good Grips POP Containers – Baking Set
SEAL: ONE-PRESS AIRTIGHT BUTTON
• FIT: PERFECTLY SIZED
• STACKING: SPACE-SAVING SQUARE SHAPE
• EXTRAS: BUILT-IN SCOOPS + SUGAR DISK
• MATERIAL: CLEAR, BPA-FREE PLASTICIf you bake frequently and want a no-fuss, all-inclusive solution, the OXO Good Grips POP baking set is my top pick. I love that it comes perfectly sized for common ingredients: two large 4.4-quart containers that each hold a whole 5-pound bag of flour or sugar, one 1.1-quart for brown sugar, and two small 0.4-quart ones for baking powder, soda, or salt. In other words, it’s tailored for a baker’s pantry. The push-button lids create an airtight seal with one press. It’s super handy when you’re in the middle of kneading dough and need to grab sugar one-handed. (Press again and the button pops up as a handle for the lid.) The containers are also stackable and space-efficient, with square sides that stack neatly on your shelf. I appreciate details like the rounded corners for easy pouring when transferring flour, and the BPA-free plastic is both sturdy and clear, so you can see when you are running low.
OXO really thought of everything a baker might need. The set includes half-cup scoops that snap under the lids for measuring, and even a little terracotta disk that keeps brown sugar soft. (No more lumps of brown sugar!) These POP containers have a bit of a cult following. In fact, Architectural Digest recently named this exact OXO set the “Best Food Storage Containers” in their 2025 pantry-organizing guide. Everyday users love it as well: one home baker raved that the containers “air-lock and will keep your food fresher for longer” and that “the included scoops are extremely convenient.” I find myself reaching for these containers constantly, and they’ve truly tamed my once-chaotic baking cabinet.
view:Best Modular Set for Pantry Organization: Tupperware Modular Mates Baking Set
STACKING: ULTRA MODULAR DESIGN
•SEAL: AIRTIGHT SNAP-ON LIDS
•BUILD: THICK, DURABLE PLASTIC
•USE: SPACE EFFICIENT FOR DEEP SHELVES
For a classic solution that gets the job done, consider Tupperware’s Modular Mates baking set. This set has been beloved by organized bakers for decades (if you inherited a piece from Mom, you know what I mean). The appeal is its modular design: each container has a low-profile shape and they’re engineered to stack like a dream, using every inch of pantry space. The Baking Set is made for deep shelves and comes with a nice mix of different sizes. You get small containers for things like baking powder, sprinkles, or packets of yeast, medium ones that are great for brown sugar, cocoa powder, or chocolate chips, and larger ones that can hold oats, powdered sugar, or shredded coconut. The biggest container in the set easily fits a full 5-pound bag of flour with room to spare. Everything stacks neatly, the lids snap on tight, and the plastic is strong but light—making it easy to keep your pantry tidy and your ingredients fresh. All the pieces have super tight snap-on lids that truly lock in freshness. And unlike the OXO set’s push buttons, Tupperware lids are simple lift-off designs, meaning fewer moving parts and nothing to potentially break over time. In fact, Tupperware is so confident in their durability that they come with a lifetime warranty against chipping, cracking, breaking, or warping.
In daily use, the plastic is thick and tinted just enough to resist UV light (keeping your flour from degrading) while still letting you see the contents. They’re lightweight but built to last. And because the set is modular, you can always expand with additional pieces that will fit perfectly alongside. One thing to note: it might take a bit of hunting to find. But it’s worth it. As one Tupperware rep put it, “this set locks in freshness and allows you to instantly see what’s inside” (which means no more mystery canisters). And knowing my baking staples are in airtight vaults gives me peace of mind.
Best Feature-Packed Set for Serious Bakers: Progressive Prepworks ProKeeper+
DESIGN: INGREDIENT SPECIFIC CONTAINERS
• TOOLS: BUILT IN SCOOPS & LEVELERS
• SEAL: SILICONE GASKETS + MAGNETS
• USE: FOR SERIOUS, FREQUENT BAKERS
• CARE: DISHWASHER SAFEBaking isn’t just a hobby for some of us – it’s pretty much a science. If you nod knowingly at that, the Progressive Prepworks ProKeeper+ set will make you very happy. This is (in my opinion) the Ultimate storage set, recently updated (hence the “+”) with even smarter features to keep baking ingredients at their best. Rather than identical canisters, the ProKeeper+ gives each ingredient its own specialized container. The 9-piece baker’s set includes: one large 4-quart flour keeper with a built-in leveler for precise measuring, a 2.4-quart sugar container with a flip-open spout for easy pouring, a 2-quart powdered sugar keeper that even comes with a dusting spoon, a 1.6-quart brown sugar container with a terra-cotta disc to keep it soft, and one mini container (0.42 qt ) with a shaker screen for things like sprinkles or baking soda. It’s insanely satisfying for an obsessive baker. I especially adore the little touches: magnets in the lids hold the accessories and everything has measuring marks on the side so you can see how many cups are left. The lids have sturdy stainless-steel hinges and silicone gaskets for an airtight seal on all sides, and the new “+” version even added better grip handles for when your hands are covered in flour.
In my experience, the ProKeeper set truly shines when you’re in the middle of a baking project. For instance, the flour container’s leveling blade means I can scoop and sweep flour right over the bin – no extra tools, no mess. One user perfectly summed this up, saying it’s “so easy to fit a measuring cup in the container and level it off with the built-in leveler,” which really “cuts down on any spilling.” The specialization also means ingredients stay in optimal condition: my brown sugar stays moist, my powdered sugar doesn’t clump, and I’m not dipping a damp measuring cup into the whole sugar supply. In fact, customers have called this set a “life changer” that makes baking easier and saves space by consolidating all those random bags into a tidy system. I also appreciate that the containers are dishwasher-safe (because life’s too short to hand-wash six different sticky canisters). If you bake often and love a clever gadget, the ProKeeper+ will feel like it was designed just for you – because, frankly, it was.
Best Clear, Airtight Set for Pantry Staples: Rubbermaid Brilliance Pantry Containers
•SEAL: 100% LEAK-PROOF DESIGN
• MATERIAL: CRYSTAL-CLEAR TRITAN
• USE: PANTRY• BUILD: STACKABLE + STAIN-RESISTANT
• EXTRAS: CLASPS LOCK IN FRESHNESS
If you’re looking for something airtight, and made specifically for dry baking ingredients, the Rubbermaid Brilliance Pantry Containers are a great option. These are designed with tight-sealing lids that latch on both sides, plus a silicone gasket that keeps air and moisture out. One Amazon reviewer noted “I’ve shaken a container full of flour just to test it, and not a speck escaped.” This level of airtightness makes them ideal for staples like sugar, flour, oats, and more.
The Pantry line comes in thoughtfully sized containers that actually match up with what bakers use: a 16-cup tall container that fits a whole five-pound bag of flour, a 12-cup one for sugar, a 7.8-cup for brown sugar, and smaller sizes that are great for things like nuts, chocolate chips, or cocoa. They’re sold in sets or as individual pieces so you can mix and match to suit your space. They also stack perfectly.
One of my favorite features is the clear Tritan plastic—they look like glass but are lightweight and won’t stain or hold odors. While they don’t come with scoops, buttons, or terra-cotta disks like some of the other sets, they make up for it in durability, clarity, and a truly tight seal. These are pantry-first containers—meant for dry goods only—and they do that job exceptionally well. If you want something clean-looking, pest-proof, and easy to organize, this set keeps things simple and dependable.
Best for Small Kitchens (Space-Saving Design): Joseph Joseph Nest Lock Storage Set
STORAGE: NESTING SPACE-SAVER
• LOCK: 4-SIDE CLIP LID SEAL
• DESIGN: COLOR-CODED MATCHING SYSTEM
• USE: BEST FOR SMALL KITCHENS
• CARE: LIGHTWEIGHT & DISHWASHER SAFENot everyone has a walk-in pantry – if you’re working with a small kitchen or limited storage, the Joseph Joseph Nest Lock set is a godsend. Joseph Joseph is known for clever space-saving designs. It includes five containers that nest perfectly inside one another (with the lids snapping together too) when not in use. This means you can store all five containers in the footprint of the largest one – a huge plus if you have just one cabinet for all your tupperware. The container sizes range from a tiny 1 cup (good for baking powder, salt, or sprinkles) up to an extra-large 12½-cup container that can hold about 3 quarts of flour or sugar. (It’s not quite as big as some others, so a full 5-lb bag of flour might need to be split, but it will comfortably fit typical sugar bags or smaller flour bags.) What’s cool is that each size has a different color lid, and the lids are color-coded to the base, so you can quickly match them. When snapped closed, the lids are airtight and leakproof, with a lock-click you can actually hear. They don’t have fancy push buttons or latches; instead, each lid has four clip-down tabs that secure it on all sides. It’s a simple mechanism that works well.
For bakers, this set is ideal if you have a more minimalist stash or buy ingredients in smaller quantities. These containers are made of BPA-free plastic that is microwave, freezer, and top-rack dishwasher safe – meaning you can use them for leftovers or freezer storage just as easily as for pantry goods. They’re truly all-purpose. I also appreciate how lightweight they are; even the largest one isn’t bulky, so it’s easy to pull down from a high cabinet. Despite being lightweight, users report they’re quite durable – the plastic resists staining and the locking tabs hold up well over time. One customer noted the “high-quality latches and hinges” and how neatly the containers stack in each other. And many love the fact that they no longer have an avalanche of mismatched plastic containers falling out of their cupboard.
While the Nest Lock set might lack some of the bells and whistles of the others, it is efficient. It’s also very affordable. At around thirty dollars for the whole five-piece set, it was the cheapest of all my recommendations, proving you don’t have to spend a fortune or have a big kitchen to keep your baking ingredients tidy. For apartment dwellers or occasional bakers, this set covers the basics without eating up space.
Each of these container sets has earned its spot by addressing a baker’s pet peeve, be it stale ingredients, spillage, or lack of space. Personally, I mix and match – my OXO set holds the everyday flour and sugar, the Progressive ProKeepers come out for specialty ingredients, and I use a few Brilliance containers for overflow (and leftover cake batter). There’s no wrong choice here, just the one that fits your kitchen and style. With any of these five sets, you’ll be all set to leave behind, the chaos of rolled-up bags and flimsy containers to a baking pantry that’s organized, efficient, and ready for your next batch of cookies.
“But what if you could make meal prep more efficient?”
NOW AVAILABLE ON SPOTIFY
